Local Favourite MLK Deli Draws Applause After Bold Move

MLK Deli in Surry Hills sparked backlash and praise after pulling its viral Risky Brisket sandwich when owner Myra Karakelle refused to serve subpar meat.

Quality Over Popularity

The Risky Brisket sandwich, packed with brisket, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut and pickles, had drawn food lovers from across Sydney. After receiving a tough cut of meat in July 2025, owner Myra Karakelle explained on Instagram and TikTok why she removed the item from the menu.

Despite complaints from customers who travelled to try it, she refused to serve anything below her standards. Karakelle stood firm, saying she’d rather lose sales than break the trust of her community. Her honest approach quickly turned online criticism into strong local support.

Community Rallies Behind MLK Deli

Under fire at first, MLK Deli’s decision soon won over the crowd, with hundreds flooding Instagram with praise for owner Myra Karakelle’s honesty. One user reversed their negative review, thanking her for “handling it beautifully,” while another called it a “brave call not serving a turd.”

Supporters chimed in with humour and heart, reminding others that one missing sandwich didn’t define the menu. The wave of support cemented why locals keep coming back.

Small Business, Big Standards

MLK Deli’s fan base in Surry Hills isn’t just chasing hype, they’re backing a business that refuses to cut corners. While food trends often reward speed and shortcuts, Myra Karakelle hit pause and chose transparency over a quick fix.

Her call to wait for better brisket, rather than serve a subpar version, struck a chord far beyond the deli’s front door. It kicked off a bigger conversation about the pressures local businesses face and the power of sticking to your values.

Turning a Setback Into Strength

Even with the brisket gone for now, MLK Deli is riding a wave of respect rather than regret. The way it handled the setback reminded people why they fell in love with the place in the first place.

One fan called it proof that real pride goes into every bite. The Risky Brisket might be on pause, but the deli’s connection with its community is only getting stronger.

Published 29-July-2025